Never actually watched any James Somerton videos before the big callouts dropped. (If you missed them, and have some time to kill: Hbomberguy’s 4-hour video about plagiarism where half of it is just Somerton, and Todd in the Shadows’ 2-hour video about the sheer amount of blatant lies he told about queer history and media.)
But the other night I ended up watching this streamed commentary/breakdown of Somerton’s Utena video:
2/3 of the way through, it’s mostly a sludge of reading off Wikipedia interspersed with lukewarm takes. Then, around 1:54:25, a line that made me stop cold and rewind to make sure I heard it right:
“…which I feel gives a lot of undue complexity to a work that is otherwise meant to just be straightforward.”
UNDUE COMPLEXITY. Utena!
Meant to just be straightforward! UTENA?!
I just
Wh
(For the sake of not spending an hour on this post, I am restraining myself from getting into the weeds about more specific stupid takes that the streamers didn’t call out already, but I can’t leave this out: He also goes on this big tangent about how Miley Cyrus doesn’t indicate anywhere in the music video for “Wrecking Ball” that the construction imagery is supposed to be symbolic? The song where, if you only know one thing about it, it’s the line about how the wrecking ball is a symbol)