erinptah: Rainbow stained glass (rainbow)
Got this adorable Yuletide gift, Wizard of Oz with a Wonderland crossover:

Blossoms (1007 words) by Anonymous
Chapters: 1/1
Fandom: Alice In Wonderland - Lewis Carroll, Oz - L. Frank Baum, The Wizard of Oz & Related Fandoms
Rating: General Audiences
Warnings: No Archive Warnings Apply
Relationships: Dorothy Gale/Princess Ozma
Characters: Princess Ozma (Oz), Dorothy Gale, Queen of Hearts (Alice in Wonderland)
Additional Tags: Diplomacy, Magical Items, Romance, Royal Visits
Summary: Dorothy and Ozma embark on their first diplomatic mission to Wonderland, and their magical gift causes a bit of acceptance to bloom for a non-magical Dorothy.

Also, a bonus rec! This was not posted for Yuletide, which might be why it hasn't gotten nearly as much attention as it deserves -- even though it's such a perfect fit for one of my previous YT prompts that it could have been. Oz with multiple crossovers:

That Bwessed Awwangement (13023 words) by EvelynJo
Chapters: 1/1
Fandom: Oz - L. Frank Baum, An Ancient Mappe of Fairyland - Bernard Sleigh
Rating: Teen And Up Audiences
Warnings: No Archive Warnings Apply
Relationships: Dorothy Gale/Princess Ozma
Characters: Princess Ozma (Oz), Dorothy Gale, Shaggy Man (Oz), Glinda the Good, Cap'n Bill Weedles
Summary: A handful of anecdotes – not much of a plot, and almost no action to speak of – of a royal wedding from the perspective of a civil servant.
erinptah: Cat in christmas lights (christmas)
Hello, prospective future Yuletide writer! I am ErinPtah on AO3, and here is my gift!fic wishlist this year.

Honestly, I will probably like anything you write for these series. If you want specific prompt ideas, I came up with some new ones this year. Requested the same canons last year, so feel free to mine my prompts from last year's letter too.


General likes:
  • hurt/comfort
  • time travel
  • culture clashes, especially one character in a fish-out-of-water situation
  • taking a weird fantasy/SF situation and earnestly thinking through the logistics
  • crossovers
  • crossdressing + gender-nonconformity

General DNWs:
  • joyless issuefic
  • character-bashing
  • hurt where the hurt character's loved ones don't care about comfort
  • mundane AUs (unless specifically prompted) for fantasy/SF canons
  • heavy references to IRL politics
  • zombies
Oz books, Moon Knight comics, Super Drags )
erinptah: Cat in christmas lights (christmas)
Hello, prospective future Yuletide writer! I am [personal profile] erinptah on the AO3, and here is my gift!fic wishlist this year.


General likes:
  • hurt/comfort
  • time travel
  • culture clashes, especially one character in a fish-out-of-water situation
  • taking a weird fantasy/SF situation and earnestly thinking through the logistics
  • crossovers
  • crossdressing + gender-nonconformity

General DNWs:
  • joyless issuefic
  • character-bashing
  • hurt where the hurt character's loved ones don't care about comfort
  • mundane AUs (unless specifically prompted) for fantasy/SF canons
  • heavy references to IRL politics
  • zombies

Dorothy and Ozma

Oz books


Characters: Dorothy, Ozma (at least one)

Likes: Dorothy coming into her own as a magic-user. The developing magitech of Oz. Diplomatic relationships with neighboring countries, especially Ev (Ozma of Oz) and the country of the Great Jinjin (Tik-Tok of Oz). Toto's deep nonverbal connection with Dorothy.

Shippy or gen is fine! Please don't pair up Dorothy or Ozma with anyone but each other; aside from that, any pairings are good.

Any take on Gender Feelings for Ozma is fine, but I'd like to see her after the "trying to figure it out" phase. Show me an Ozma who already found a comfortable gender space, moved in, and picked out the curtains.

Books are public domain, so you can read them all for free on Project Gutenberg! (And there's a series of reread reaction posts on my Land-of-Oz tag.)


Optional specific prompts:

- Dorothy/Ozma wedding fic. If Ozma's birthday was a book-defining event, the Royal Wedding of Oz must be even more extravagant. What are the Oz traditions here? What elements do Henry and Em suggest from Kansas-style weddings? How many more different magical countries (maybe from crossover series -- Narnia, Labyrinth, Wonderland, Arendelle) send guests? Who tries and fails to crash the party?

- A mini-adventure with Dorothy and the Patchwork Girl. Something that shows off how Scraps has brains as good as the Scarecrow, she's just a lot more whimsical in how she uses them.

- Dorothy goes back to the US for a visit (maybe to see all-grown-up Cousin Zeb? or his descendants?), and it's nothing but culture clashes now that she's grown up with Oz norms. Extra bonus points if she brings Ozma, who has it even worse.


Jake and Steven scolding Marc

Moon Knight (Comics)

Characters: Steven, Jake (all)

Likes: Headmates who love and support each other -- no matter how much heckling, power-struggling, and bickering they put each other through. Superhero characters who need therapy, and are actually getting it (and it's not a magic fix, but it sure is better than nothing). Characters who only interacted with one member of Team Moon Knight in the past, getting cautiously introduced to the whole system. Unlikely friendships between all the different weird types of people that exist in the Marvel universe.

Any combination of gen or shipping between Marc+Steven+Jake is good with me.

If you include any of their canon romances, please focus on the good parts! For example, I'd be great with "system watching movies with Tigra and her kid" or "Marlene walks in on Marc practicing superhero catchphrases," but I don't want to read about "Marc making Tigra cry on a rooftop" or "Marlene walks in on Marc wearing a dead guy's face."


Optional specific prompts:

- We now have a 616 version of Layla El-Faouly!...but the writing in the City of The Dead miniseries has been discontinuous and uncomfortable in a lot of ways. Can I get a backstory for "how Layla found out about the DID" that makes sense for the comicverse characters? It's weird for her to know the actual medical diagnosis, since he was still in denial about needing one for a lot of his early Moon Knighting years, and this Layla's relationship with Marc was all pre-Khonshu...but let her meet Steven and Jake. Have them pop out for some reason during a mercenary job. Give Layla a chance to ask questions -- not invasive "let me dissect you" questions, but reasonable "if I'm going to date this guy, I'd like to know what his deal is" questions.

- Fic about the House of Shadows enthusiastically taking care of its new residents. I got one of these last year, would read a hundred more. Does an eldritch interdimensional piece of sentient architecture understand what squishy depressed mortals need? Not really! Is it going to do its very best anyway? Sure is. Feel free to take this in a "wacky hijinks" direction, or a "psychological horror hurt/comfort" direction.

- Headspace sex, making use of the different internal settings we've seen. I'm thinking they have fun with scenarios like "Jake shows up to fix the plumbing at Steven's office, seduces him on his desk" or "stealing Captain Spector's spacecraft, flying it to the Planet of Makeouts, and getting it on in the back seat." Maybe when Steven or Jake is fronting, the other one uses this to keep Marc distracted so he doesn't get in the way...

Vel and Malori

Mage & Demon Queen (Webcomic)

Characters: Malori, Velverosa (all)

Likes: Malori's shameless thirst. The other demons' shameless shipping. The comedy in general. I loved the long-term slow-burn of Vel coming to accept Malori's feelings, but I'm also delighted that they Actually Got Together and the comic is still going. Not super gripped by the political intrigue, other than hoping it all works out. I do like Leora, though.

Shippy or gen is fine, just please don't pair Malori or Vel with anyone but each other! ...Unless you're thinking polycule.

Read the comic for free here!


Optional specific prompts:

- Vel/Malori, sex with hijinks! Are they trying to hide from a nosy underling? Are human and demon kinks/erogenous zones/basic sexual functions different in surprising ways? Does Vel uncontrollably turn into a dragon when she's turned-on enough? Make it magic, make it weird, make it fun.

- Reverse isekai where Malori gets summoned into Cerik's world. Maybe she has some form of communication with her friends back home, so Cerik can give advice (and everyone else can try to give advice)? But the fish-out-of-water awkwardness is strong.

- Setting AU that give Malori/Vel a different dynamic than human/demon. Sci-fi where Vel is the alien queen? Cyberpunk where Vel is a sentient virus? Superhero where Vel is that one powerful politician who's trying to get heroes canceled? (A few years ago, I wrote "Locked Tomb AU where Vel is a Resurrection Beast" mostly as a joke, then Nona the Ninth has come out...)


And finally...

Was anybody going to tell me that Netflix has a saucy original comedy about magical drag queens?


Super Drags posing

Super Drags (Cartoon)

Characters: Patrick | Lemon, Ralph | Safira (at least one)

Likes: The affectionate parody of magical-girl tropes. The way it's overtly, messily pro-queer, full of love and support for a wide range of people with all their different strengths and flaws. The way it manages to pair "thoughtful, nuanced portrayal of inter-community issues" with "there is a dick-shaped robot assistant called D.I.L.D.O."

Canon-typical levels of ridiculous sex jokes not required, but if you go for that, I'll enjoy it. (Some of these prompts have younger kid characters in them; I would also like a canon-typical level of "not involving the kids in the sex jokes.")

Shippy or gen is fine, all ships are fine. Ralph/Junior Pedroso was adorable, but feel free to pair either with somebody else, too.

I wrote a whole post gushing about this series the year it came out, with links to trailers and other promo material! Feel free to mine that for other canon feelings/potential story hooks.

Optional specific prompts:

- Future fic where Ralph's little sister comes out as some flavor of LGBTQ (pick a letter, any letter), and they do queer sibling bonding. Going to a Pride parade? Or a drag show? The sister having a crush on someone, and Ralph being a terrible overenthusiastic wingman?

- Do the Sailor Moon riff: somebody's kid from the future drops out of the sky, and tells the present-day Super Drags they need to stop villains from taking over the world. Your choice which Super Drag is the parent! Any of them has potential for a ton of funny reactions from the other two.

- Crossover with another magical-girl series (or several!), helping solve their problems. Maybe by teaching them to channel their Highlight (have you ever seen a straight magical girl), maybe just with an overwhelming show of sass and dick jokes. I'm the biggest fan of Sailor Moon and Madoka Magica; would also be into Tokyo Mew Mew, Princess Tutu, Revolutionary Girl Utena, Cardcaptor Sakura, even Miraculous Ladybug or Steven Universe. Or introduce me to something new!
erinptah: Cat in christmas lights (christmas)
Hello, prospective future Yuletide writer! I am [personal profile] erinptah on the AO3, and here is my gift!fic wishlist this year.


General likes:
  • hurt/comfort
  • time travel
  • culture clashes, especially one character in a fish-out-of-water situation
  • taking a weird fantasy/SF situation and earnestly thinking through the logistics
  • crossovers
  • crossdressing + gender-nonconformity

General DNWs:
  • joyless issuefic
  • character-bashing
  • hurt where the hurt character's close family/friends/loved ones never care about offering comfort
  • mundane AUs (unless specifically prompted) for fantasy/SF canons
  • heavy references to IRL politics
  • zombies


Oz books


Characters: Dorothy, Ozma

Likes: Dorothy coming into her own as a magic-user. The developing magitech of Oz. Diplomatic relationships with neighboring countries, especially Ev (Ozma of Oz) and the country of the Great Jinjin (Tik-Tok of Oz). Toto's deep nonverbal connection with Dorothy.

Shippy or gen is fine! Please don't pair up Dorothy or Ozma with anyone but each other; aside from that, any pairings are good.

Any take on Gender Feelings for Ozma is fine, but I'd like to see her after the "trying to figure it out" phase. I've already read (and received) (and written!) a good amount of "uncertain Ozma does gender-related experiments" fics -- show me an Ozma who already found a comfortable gender space and is joyfully inhabiting it.

I did a major Baum reread a few years ago; there are reaction posts on my land-of-Oz tag. Feel free to mine that for other canon feelings/potential story hooks.

Optional specific prompts:

- Dorothy/Ozma wedding fic. If Ozma's birthday was a book-defining event, the Royal Wedding of Oz must be even more extravagant. What are the Oz traditions here? What elements do Henry and Em suggest from Kansas-style weddings? How many more different magical countries (maybe from crossover series -- Narnia, Labyrinth, Wonderland, Arendelle) send guests? Who tries and fails to crash the party?

- A mini-adventure with Dorothy and the Patchwork Girl. Something that shows off how Scraps has brains as good as the Scarecrow, she's just a lot more whimsical in how she uses them.

- Dorothy goes back to the US for a visit (maybe to see all-grown-up Cousin Zeb? or his descendants?), and it's nothing but culture clashes now that she's grown up with Oz norms. Extra bonus points if she brings Ozma, who has it even worse.



Moon Knight (Comics)

Characters: Marc, Steven, Jake, House of Shadows

Likes: Headmates who love and support each other -- no matter how much heckling, power-struggling, and bickering they put each other through. Superhero characters who need therapy, and are actually getting it (and it's not a magic fix, but it sure is better than nothing). Characters who only interacted with one member of Team Moon Knight in the past, getting cautiously introduced to the whole system. Unlikely friendships between all the different weird types of people that exist in the Marvel universe.

Any combination of gen or shipping between Marc+Steven+Jake is good with me. References to other romances they've had (canon or not) are also fine, just please don't make them the focus.


Optional specific prompts:

- The House of Shadows enthusiastically taking care of its new residents. Does an eldritch interdimensional piece of sentient architecture understand what squishy depressed mortals need? Not really! Is it going to do its very best anyway? Sure is. Feel free to take this in a "wacky hijinks" direction, or a "psychological horror hurt/comfort" direction.

- Just, everyone in their life getting to meet (and be a little creeped out by) the House. Dr. Sterman visits for a bonus "family therapy" session. Daredevil or Black Panther stops in for a surprise spot-check, and Marc has to chastise the House not to eat them. Tigra does her very best to resist scratching up the House's furniture.

- Headspace sex, making use of the different internal settings we've seen. I'm thinking they have fun with scenarios like "Jake shows up to fix the plumbing at Steven's office, seduces him on his desk" or "stealing Captain Spector's spacecraft, flying it to the Sea of Makeouts, and getting it on in the back seat." Maybe when Steven or Jake is fronting, the other one has to keep Marc distracted so he doesn't get in the way...


Mage & Demon Queen (Webcomic)

Characters: Malori, Velverosa

Likes: Malori's shameless thirst. The other demons' shameless shipping. The comedy in general. I loved the long-term slow-burn of Vel coming to accept Malori's feelings, but I'm also delighted that they Actually Got Together and the comic is still going. Not super gripped by the political intrigue, other than hoping it all works out. I do like Leora, though.

Read the comic for free here!


Optional specific prompts:

- Vel/Malori, sex with hijinks! Are they trying to hide from a nosy underling? Are human and demon kinks/erogenous zones/basic sexual functions different in surprising ways? Does Vel uncontrollably turn into a dragon when she's turned-on enough? Make it magic, make it weird, make it fun.

- Reverse isekai where Malori gets summoned into Cerik's world. Maybe she has some form of communication with her friends back home, so Cerik can give advice (and everyone else can try to give advice)? But the fish-out-of-water awkwardness is strong.

- Setting AU that give Malori/Vel a different dynamic than human/demon. Sci-fi where Vel is the alien queen? Cyberpunk where Vel is a sentient virus? Superhero where Vel is that one powerful politician who's trying to get heroes canceled? (Last year, I wrote "Locked Tomb AU where Vel is a Resurrection Beast" mostly as a joke, this year Nona the Ninth has come out and I'm all, wait...)
erinptah: Cat in christmas lights (christmas)

Other people get candy or toys in their stockings, I got the Omicron variant. Lucky me.

…seriously, though, it was the better kind of COVID experience. No hospital, no breathing problems, no need for any of the expensive treatments that are in short supply. I just canceled holiday plans, spent a few days sleeping a lot, had a friend drop off some chicken soup, and used over-the-counter fever/cough/etc meds to keep the symptoms in check.

Over a week of doing that, my immune system wrestled it steadily down from “thoroughly miserable” to “minor sniffles.”

And if you’ve been hearing people on the news panic about how Booster Shots Wear Off In Weeks And Then Omicron Can Kill Us All…listen, I didn’t even have a booster. Probably could’ve had milder symptoms if I did? But even un-boosted, the two regular Pfizer doses I got back in summer had the virus handled.

(The cat helped, I’m sure. He was very fierce at it. Scared it right off.)

Marshmallow Fluff having a Christmas nap

I had almost wrestled my Marked For Later list down to 5 pages when Yuletide dropped, and now it’s overflowing. At least reading has been easy for most of the COVID recovery period, so I’ve had time to start making a dent again.

I got 2 gifts!

A delightful comedy about Gideon, Harrow, and associates having low-stakes adventures, with Earth artifacts and attempted wrestling:

fifteen percent concentrated power of will (9120 words) by Anonymous
Chapters: 1/1
Fandom: The Locked Tomb Series | Gideon the Ninth Series – Tamsyn Muir
Rating: Not Rated
Warnings: No Archive Warnings Apply
Relationships: Gideon Nav/Harrowhark Nonagesimus
Characters: Gideon Nav, Harrowhark Nonagesimus, Coronabeth Tridentarius, Judith Deuteros, Camilla Hect
Additional Tags: 5 things (kind of), gideon nav: personal trainer
Summary:

Teaching someone to do a push-up is a love language, when that person is very annoying.

And a treat about Dorothy learning some finer details of Oz magic:

A Long Winter in Oz (14928 words) by Anonymous
Chapters: 5/5
Fandom: Oz – L. Frank Baum
Rating: Teen And Up Audiences
Warnings: No Archive Warnings Apply
Relationships: Dorothy Gale & Glinda the Good, Dorothy Gale/Princess Ozma
Characters: Dorothy Gale, Glinda the Good
Additional Tags: Magic, Friendship, Minor Character Death, Implied/Referenced Suicide, no canon character deaths, Romance is a minor element, Worldbuilding
Summary:

Dorothy decides that she ought to learn about magic properly and there just so happens to be a long winter approaching.

erinptah: Cat in christmas lights (christmas)

It started snowing on the night before Christmas, and kept going on-and-off ever since, so everything outside the window is carpeted with perfect winter scenery. Seeing as I don't have anywhere to go, this has been great.

I got an absolutely heartwarming Yuletide fic, a new take on "Ozma decides to spend some time in Tip form", featuring some quality Worried Dorothy and Protective Aunt Em:

Homecoming (6127 words) by Anonymous
Chapters: 1/1
Fandom: Oz - L. Frank Baum
Rating: General Audiences
Warnings: No Archive Warnings Apply
Relationships: Dorothy Gale/Princess Ozma
Characters: Princess Ozma, Dorothy Gale, Aunt Em
Additional Tags: Comfort, Genderqueer Character, genderqueer character misread as male, mentions of past emotional / physical abuse, aunt em has a bunch of unexamined gender and class biases
Summary:

A nice young person with experience on a farm comes to help Aunt Em with the chores for a celebration.
Meanwhile, Ozma isn't in the Palace, and Dorothy goes looking for them.

More rec posts to come. I've been churning my way through all the promising-looking fandoms, trying to read everything in-the-moment instead of letting it disappear into marked For Later.

...with the exception of a bunch of Locked Tomb fics, because I'm still only 80% through Harrow the Ninth (the second novel), and any time I've looked at post-Harrow writing for more than 5 seconds I've been spoiled for something. (Fortunately, there are So Many wild and unpredictable twists that it's turned out I was still unspoiled for most of them.)


On less fandom-y notes:

Half my family is being scrupulous and careful about COVID restrictions, and the other half is...not. I don't know what to say. They've already had two scares (notable COVID-like symptoms that ended up testing negative), you'd think that would make them more cautious, not less. The hospitals are full of people who thought "oh, nothing bad will happen to me." And by "full" I mean record-breaking cases, record-breaking deaths, "lining up beds in the hallways because all the rooms are occupied" full.

This Week In Virology had a good discussion of the new COVID variant that's developed in the UK, including a breakdown of why it's not likely to be more vaccine-resistant than any other variant. There is a serious chance it's more transmissible, but even if that's true, it's not so transmissible that it can overcome all the usual measures -- keeping distances, wearing masks, washing hands.

So we just have to stay serious about doing those.

erinptah: Cat in christmas lights (christmas)
Hello, prospective future Yuletide writer! I am [archiveofourown.org profile] ErinPtah on the AO3, and here is my gift!fic wishlist this year.


erinptah: (Default)
Hello, prospective future Yuletide writer! I am [archiveofourown.org profile] ErinPtah on the AO3, and here is my gift!fic wishlist this year.


erinptah: (Default)
After putting it off long enough, I finally went through the last two of Baum's Oz books. Both published posthumously, in case this wasn't sad enough already.

Book 13 is The One With The Even Gayer Birthday Party, and Book 14 is Baum Breaks His Own Record For Unnecessary Cameos.

***

The Magic of Oz opens with a baby supervillain. Munchkin boy Kiki Aru discovers a magic word of transformation, and decides to fly over the Deadly Desert and visit other countries, then come back to Oz and maybe take it over.

(So of course the readers all had to figure out how to stumble through pronouncing "pyrzqxgl." Wish some of them had thought to go back and distort the audio, so what the listener hears is something they genuinely can't repeat back.)

Baum sure does have a thing for fantasy young boy protagonists vs. mundane young girl protagonists, huh? On the one side, Dorothy, Dot, Trot, and Betsy; on the other, Ojo, Woot, Inga, and Kiki, plus I'll throw in Tip, who considers himself male for the bulk of the book in which he's the focus of the adventure.

Mundane boys: Tot, Button-Bright. Fantasy girls: Ozma, and...is that it? There are Polychrome and Ann Soforth, but they both feel like young adults to me.

Anyway.

Didn't even plan this: Kiki Aru drops in on exactly the non-Oz countries from my last review. Hiland, Loland, Merryland, Nol, and Ix.

He ends up in Ev, where he tries to crash at an inn for the night, only to realize that -- worldbuilding! -- Ev uses money, and he doesn't have any. You'd think he could turn into a bird in order to sleep in a tree, but as a baby supervillain he decides to turn into a bird in order to steal someone else's coins.

The ex-Nome King just happens to be in the area, and approves. "I like you, young man, and I'll go to the inn with you if you'll promise not to eat eggs for supper."

***

It's almost Ozma's birthday again! Look, it was a serviceable plot device the first time around, no reason not to bring it back.

Dorothy is stuck for gift ideas, which is bound to happen when you've been living with someone for, what is it, 30 years now? The Scarecrow is providing a straw-themed gift, and the Tin Woodman a tin-themed gift, but Dorothy doesn't exactly have a theme.

Scraps wrote a song! The title begins "When Ozma Has a Birthday, Everybody's Sure to Be Gay..." ("I am patched and gay and glary / You're a sweet and lovely fairy.")

Toto's advice:

"Tell me, Toto," said the girl; "what would Ozma like best for a birthday present?"

The little black dog wagged his tail.

"Your love," said he. "Ozma wants to be loved more than anything else."

"But I already love her, Toto!"

"Then tell her you love her twice as much as you ever did before."

"That wouldn't be true," objected Dorothy, "for I've always loved her as much as I could, and, really, Toto, I want to give Ozma some PRESENT, 'cause everyone else will give her a present."


Glinda suggests Dorothy bake Ozma a cake. Then suggests she put something surprising inside the cake. When asked for specific ideas, she says that has to be up to Dorothy. HMMMM.

Everyone ships it, is what I'm saying.

(Her eventual big plan for the surprise: tiny monkeys that do tricks! She decides to ask the Wizard for help, because she has no idea how to (a) hire monkeys, (b) make them tiny, or (c) teach them tricks.)

***

Worldbuilding update: they've decided they aren't sure whether immigrants to Oz are affected by the "can't be killed" rule, so Dorothy et al are carefully protected.

Trot, Cap'n Bill, and the Glass Cat head out on their own sidequest: to bring Ozma a magic flower that only grows on a secluded island. As with The Scarecrow of Oz, Trot is missing a lot of the personality she had in her own books. Sigh.

I was going to say "at least she gets a quest," unlike Betsy, whose only adventuring since moving to Oz has been her bit part in Lost Princess -- but on second thought, Betsy being a homebody who didn't care for her first adventure and would rather avoid having more of them is a nice way to distinguish her from Trot and Dorothy. Let the girl have a quiet, uneventful life at the palace for a few more decades. She's earned it.

About that island: it turns out to be creepily bare ("How funny it is, Cap'n Bill, that nothing else grows here excep' the Magic Flower"). Turns out it's because any living creature that sets foot on the island puts down roots.

***

Ruggedo and Kiki Aru take on some chimera forms, fly back to Oz, and land in a Gillikin forest with an animal kingdom.

Kiki Aru provides the transformations -- he's smart enough not to let Ruggedo in on the magic word -- while Ruggedo does the planning and the talking. He spins a tale that the people of the Emerald City are plotting to invade the forest and enslave the animals, so clearly they need to attack first and enslave the people instead. Based on hearsay from some creatures they've never seen or heard of before. Yep.

The animals are...admirably skeptical. Kiki Aru transforms a couple of them, backing up the "we're magicians" part of the story, but nothing more.

And this is the point where Dorothy and the Wizard just walk in. Or rather, ride in on the backs of a giant frickin' lion and tiger, while the transformed Ruggedo is all ::sweats nervously:: in the background.

The Lion introduces himself: "I am called the 'Cowardly Lion,' and I am King of all Beasts, the world over." The response boils down to "I didn't vote for you."

Dorothy and the Wizard are just here to hire some monkeys, but baby supervillain Kiki panics and does a rapid round of transformations on them. Plus on Ruggedo -- who gets to be a goose, which terrifies him, because what if he lays an egg?

Eventually the Wizard (as a fox) catches up with them, overhears Kiki saying the magic word, and uses it to turn Kiki and Ruggedo into nuts.

***

Honestly, it's kinda refreshing how fast the invasion subplot peters out. The animals realize the "magicians" were full of it, and immediately drop their halfhearted sense of grudge. A bunch of monkeys even agree to come join them for the party.

The Glass Cat catches up with them to explain what's happened to Trot and Cap'n Bill, they take a detour to wrap up that subplot too, and everyone goes home for the party.

"You will have noticed that the company at Ozma's banquet table was somewhat mixed." Heh.

Character apparent-age update:

When Dorothy and Trot and Betsy Bobbin and Ozma were together, one would think they were all about of an age, and the fairy Ruler no older and no more "grown up" than the other three. She would laugh and romp with them in regular girlish fashion, yet there was an air of quiet dignity about Ozma, even in her merriest moods, that, in a manner, distinguished her from the others. The three girls loved her devotedly, but they were never able to quite forget that Ozma was the Royal Ruler of the wonderful Fairyland of Oz, and by birth belonged to a powerful race.


It isn't until the last chapter that the Wizard finally remembers about the nuts in his pocket.

I've complained about the protagonist-centered morality before, and the ending here might be the most head-desky example on the whole series. Ozma, Dorothy, and the Wizard talk about not knowing how powerful the mystery magicians might be...but unlike with the invading armies from book 6, they're not facing a concrete threat of overwhelming force. It's just a guess. And we, the readers, know for a fact that Kiki Aru is just a kid who knows one trick, while the other nut is Ruggedo, nobody they can't handle.

In spite of this, the characters repeat the "manipulate the attackers into drinking the Water of Oblivion" trick. They recognize Ruggedo, but have no idea who Kiki is, and don't bother to ask before he takes a drink. So the kid loses his identity...and all memory of the family he left at the beginning of the book. Now they'll never find out what happened to their son.

Dammit, Baum, magically lobotomizing characters you don't like is not a happy ending!

----

Which brings us to Glinda of Oz, another of those books where the title character isn't the focus, and in fact is only around for half of the story.

It starts as a Dorothy-and-Ozma quest, kicked off when they visit Glinda, read in her Magic Book about a war brewing between two isolated communities, and decide to go intervene.

At Glinda's place: "Ozma took the arm of her hostess, but Dorothy lagged behind, kissing some of the maids she knew best, talking with others, and making them all feel that she was their friend." I've joked about Ozma's harem, but whoo boy, Dorothy isn't doing so bad herself.

Some final retconning: people in Oz can't die *or* suffer "any great bodily pain." So even if you get put through the torn-to-pieces-and-scattered-across-the-world horror show, at least it won't hurt!

***

The warring communities are the Flatheads, who have no room for brains in their heads but compensate by carrying some around in cans, and the Skeezers, who live on a sinkable island in a lake.

Both of them have fairly terrible, selfish, dictatorial rulers...but both of them make the point that they've never heard of Ozma, didn't know their lands had been declared within the borders of a country called Oz, and so why should they acknowledge her as their ruler the moment she shows up on their doorstep?

Oh, goody, marriage-is-awful jokes:

"I'm sorry we couldn't have roast pig," said the [Supreme Dictator of the Flatheads], "but as the only pig we have is made of gold, we can't eat her. Also the Golden Pig happens to be my wife, and even were she not gold I am sure she would be too tough to eat."


The Skeezers' island sinks while Dorothy and Ozma are on it, and the ruler gets turned into a swan before she can bring it back up, so they're stuck for a while. Baum indulges in some pretty description of the undersea environment. Reminds me of The Sea Fairies.

A bunch of reviews claim this is one of the darker Oz books. It's really not! Remember the first book, where Dorothy and her companions went through multiple fights to the death, and for a while Dorothy was in forced servitude to the Wicked Witch and spent her nights crying alone in the dark? Now here, Dorothy is imprisoned in a place with gorgeous scenery, the company of her best friend, and total confidence they'll get rescued sooner or later. Her biggest fear is getting bored while they wait.

***

Glinda resurfaces (hah!) in chapter 13 of 24. She sinks a model island in a pond near her home, for the purpose of testing various island-raising magics.

I was just thinking how comparatively nice it was to have a stripped-down party, just Dorothy and Ozma...and then in chapter 15 it seems like half the Emerald City heads out to rescue them. The Scarecrow, the Tin Woodman, the Lion, Scraps, Button-Bright, Ojo, the Glass Cat, Tik-Tok, Jack Pumpkinhead, the Woggle-Bug, the Shaggy Man, Cap'n Bill, Trot, Betsy, the Frogman, Uncle Henry (but for some reason not Aunt Em), the Wizard, AND Glinda.

That's eighteen people! Tik-Tok, the Woggle-bug, the Lion, and Jack don't get any lines once the quest is underway. Shaggy, Cap'n Bill and Uncle Henry get one line apiece. One!

Gratuitous magical gizmo for the Wizard: a skeropythrope. He never leaves home without one.

***

All this is doubly superfluous because most of the conflict gets solved by the Rightful Rulers of the Flatheads, working together with a Plucky Skeezer Lad. Also, another magic-user (a Yookoohoo, same type as Mrs. Yoop) who gets talked into helping via reverse psychology.

(The Yookoohoo, Red Reera, is another shapeshifter, and apparently Baum's original manuscript had her appear as a wired-together skeleton with glowing eyes. Okay, that's appreciably dark. In the published book, she spends most of her time as an ape.)

Dorothy has a good moment where she figures out how to raise the island. The magic was designed by one person, the Skeezers' usurper queen, so all she has to do is apply the psychology of the individual. Well done.

In a nice reversal, the end sees the Flatheads all transformed to have round heads, with space to safely store their brains. So they're much less likely to get lobotomized now.

And the Skeezers get to elect their new ruler! They pick Lady Aurex, a sweet, subversive courtier who took care of Dorothy and Ozma while they were prisoners. Good choice.

The moral of the story, according to Ozma, is that it's always important to do your duty -- meaning her royal duty to step in when a war is brewing, and bring the diplomacy.

The moral of the story, it seems to me, is that you shouldn't send twenty characters to do a quest that needs, like...six, max.

Especially since it really seems like the locals had this covered! Which is, to be fair, not a bad note to leave the series on. Oz is in good hands.
erinptah: (Default)

Only two Oz books left in the reread.  I'm dragging it out with some of Baum's other works.

...so I had this mostly geared up last Monday, and then, uh, some stuff happened that took precedence. And there will be more election-handling signal-boosting posts to come. But for now, let's take a trip back to the beginning of the 20th century...in the fun children's-fantasy way, not the way the Republican Party wants to take the country for real.

---

Dot and Tot in Merryland

From general osmosis I thought Dot and Tot were magical children, but no, Dot is a normal American kid! In contrast to Dorothy's poverty, Dot (full name Evangeline Josephine Freeland) is the daughter of a banker. Grew up with servants, they own multiple residences, her mom does a health-improving tour of Europe without any detriment to her finances. Tot is the gardener's boy, a little younger, reminiscent (preminiscent?) of Button-Bright's first appearance.

Looks like this is the first book Baum published after Oz became a runaway hit? He's not very creative with names yet, is he. Dorothy and Toto; Dot and Tot.

The kids are in a boat that comes loose, and drift through a cave and into the valleys of Merryland. There's a clown valley, a candy valley...the Queen is a doll, and lives in the Valley of the Dolls. Kitty valley, toy-animal valley, and eerie Valley of Lost Things.

It's...remarkably boring. The valleys are themed based on Stuff Kids Like, which feels like pandering without a whole lot of thought put into it -- and it falls flat, because "I like watching clowns" doesn't necessarily mean "I like reading about fictional characters observing that they like watching clowns."

We only get tiny blips of conflict, like when Tot eats a Candy Man's thumb. (Dorothy notices the missing thumb in Road to Oz. Continuity!)

I do like the running gag of never getting an answer about the Queen's name until the very end.

***

So I'm listening to a charmingly bland passage about the valley of the candy people, when OH SNAP suddenly I can tell you why this book hasn't stood the test of time.

A man made of marshmallows abruptly throws out this gem:

"One of our greatest troubles is that we cannot depend upon our colored servants, who are chocolate. Chocolates can seldom be depended on, you know."

Aaaand not long afterward: chocolate "serving maids, with complexions so dark brown in color that Dot was almost afraid of them." WOW.

The illustrations, too -- I looked it up on Gutenberg -- aren't shy about things like golliwog dolls. (The cooks are black dolls and the chambermaids are china dolls. Good lord.)

...It occurs to me that, since this is from 1901, the whole "comparing black people to chocolate" trope might actually have seemed like a clever innovation at the time? But whoo boy has that not aged well.

(Things that don't age well even though they weren't a problem to start with: the valley of cats features liberal description of "pussies.")

Verdict: Technically better-crafted than Mo, not as good as the Trot books, maybe on a par with the worse Oz books...but holy cow, that overt racism. Skippable.

***

Zixi of Ix (or, The Magic Cloak)

This one was originally written as a serial for a magazine (and it shows). The plot flips between Ix and Noland, both countries whose royalty also showed up at Ozma's party.

King Bud and his sister Princess Fluff sounded older at the party, but here the country of Noland seems almost unmagical, and they start off as normal kids. The king dies; some obscure statute says the 47th person to come in the capitol city's gate the next morning is the new king; and, whoops, it's the recently-orphaned Bud.

(Real names: Margaret and two-years-younger Timothy. Baum sure does love writing kids with weird nicknames.)

Meanwhile, the faeries have made a magic cloak because they were bored, and gave it to Fluff. It grants wishes, and she cheerfully lends it out to people indiscriminately, so accidental havoc-wreaking wishes ensue. Things like "I wish I could fly" or "I wish I was ten feet tall."

The palace has lightning rods! Modern!

Shameless references to children getting whipped. Un-modern.

The sentence-by-sentence writing in this one is really solid. Good scene-setting. Good dry wit. When the councilors are initially debating what to base their decisions on:

"This book of laws was written years ago and was meant to be used when the king was absent or ill or asleep."

And this is from when Bud first takes office:

"Just now it is your duty to hear the grievances of your people," answered Tallydab gently.

"What's the matter with 'em?" asked Bud crossly. "Why don't they keep out of trouble?"

"I do not know, your Majesty, but there are always disputes among the people."

"But that isn't the king's fault, is it?" said Bud.

Enjoyable, thoughtful scenes about what it's actually like for a kid to suddenly have absolute power. Like, there's an unusually subtle mix of "from the mouths of babes" and "you just got conned, because you have no idea how to do this."

***

We're almost halfway through the book (chapter 10 of 23) when we actually pay a visit to Ix, which appears to be another mostly-mundane country, except that Queen Zixi is a witch of 683 years old who still looks 16. (The rest of the populace ages normally. Reference to old men whose grandfathers remembered how Zixi was just as pretty when they were kids.)

Ouch:

"...for newsmongers, as everyone knows, were ever unable to stick to facts since the world began."

Sudden body horror, yikes. "To mortal eyes Zixi was charming and attractive, yet her reflection in a mirror showed to her an ugly old hag, bald of head, wrinkled, with toothless gums and withered, sunken cheeks."

And that's why Zixi vows to steal Fluff's cloak.

Geez, from her presentation at Ozma's party (...and, let's face it, her name alone), I was expecting her to be generally Ozma-esque, much the way Betsy is Trot-esque. Not so!

Her first scheme is downright Pratchettian:

Then Zixi had printed on green paper a lot of handbills which read as follows:

"MISS TRUST, a pupil of the celebrated Professor Hatrack of
Hooktown-on-the-Creek, is now located at Woodbine Villa (North Gateway of
Nole) and is prepared to teach the young ladies of this city the
Arts of Witchcraft according to the most modern and approved methods. Terms
moderate. References required."

Even more so when she says "all right kids, come in tomorrow wearing your best cloaks!" -- and Fluff's immediate response is to think "huh, that sounds really suspiciously specific."

I'm really sad that Ixi only keeps this up for like a chapter before deciding "screw it, I'm just gonna declare war on Noland."

***

"Yet I can never resist admiring a fine soldier, whether he fights for or against me. For instance, just look at that handsome officer riding beside Queen Zixi—her chief general, I think. Isn't he sweet? He looks just like an apple, he is so round and wears such a tight-fitting jacket. Can't you pick him for me, friend Tellydeb?"

(That's from Tollydob, one of the councilors. I could ship it.)

The war is also won by Nol pretty fast. You can tell Baum is constantly working in a mindset of "better wrap things up, the next chapter might be my last -- oh, it won't? -- okay, better make up a whole new conflict, and fast." Like a TV writer, only more so.

Zixi finally gets ahold of the cloak by getting herself hired as a maid, making an imitation cloak, and swapping it for Fluff's in a game of Duck Season/Wabbit Season. So technically it's not stolen, and the magic works.

Although she still screws up her wish. Sigh.

By the way, this book is blissfully racism-free, but it does give us this bit of unnecessary meanness:

"Why do you sob?" questioned the queen.

"Because I want to be a man," replied the child, trying to stifle her sobs.

"Why do you want to be a man?" asked Zixi curiously.

"Because I'm a little girl," was the reply.

This made Zixi angry. "You're a little fool!" she exclaimed loudly.

I'm just going to pretend that was a trans girl wishing she was a cis man. Makes it all the better when, in a chapter or so, she's decided to love and accept herself for who she is.

***

Two-thirds of the way through, Zixi wanders out of the narrative completely, and in bounce a civilization of rubber people living up in the mountains. Baum sure loves his bouncy people, huh?

They decide to take over Nol, and do a much better job of it than Ix did. Especially since the kids don't have the real cloak to use in self-defense anymore. So they decide:

"Well, there's no one else we can trust, so we may as well try Zixi."

Seems like a fast turnaround for an Enemy Mine situation, but okay.

What finally ends the story is that the fairy queen Lulea comes to get her cloak back. She's sick of it being used for silly things. Bud complains that it's not fair: he didn't get a wish, because he's been holding off until he had a really good idea.

And Lulea lets him have one! So instead of being a clunky Aesop about not putting things off, it becomes a story about how taking your time and thinking about your decisions is valuable, and wise queenly types appreciate it.

"I wish," announced Bud gravely, "that I shall become the best king that Noland has ever had!"

Epilogue says that it works! Plus, Fluff later marries the unnamed prince of an unspecified kingdom, and is also a good queen.

***

John Dough and the Cherub

This one's all plot.

A Mysterious Arab(TM) named Ali Dubh has been hoarding the Water of Life for years now, the latest in a long line of hoarders, but since he's being chased by people who want to steal it, he gives it to someone else to keep safe...and makes the mistake of choosing a French-American baker couple, who promptly accidentally use it to bring a five-foot-tall gingerbread man to life.

John Dough is another animated-artificial-humanoid in the vein of the Scarecrow or Jack Pumpkinhead, whose main goal in life is not to be destroyed (in his case, eaten). He starts off in the mundane US, but a Fourth-of-July firework takes him to the unsubtly-named Isle of Phreex, and from there he journeys through a series of weird islands trying to stay one step ahead of Ali Dubh.

For the record: while the whole "sinister Arab antagonist" thing is awfully sketchy, at least this time Baum doesn't put in anything about how all Arabs are [insert stereotype here].

On Phreex, John meets Chick the Cherub, who immediately decides to be his best friend. Chick's whole backstory is so trippy. Apparently "putting a baby in an incubator" is the 1910s equivalent of the 1960s "accidental dose of gamma radiation" -- a plausible-sounding excuse for all kinds of bizarre physical traits. No parents! Incredibly intelligent! Needs a special exotic diet! (Conveniently, it excludes gingerbread, so John has no fear Chick will eat him.)

And this is fun: Chick is canon nonbinary. And/or intersex. It's not clear how much Baum knew about either issue, but we do know is that the writing plays a strong game of pronoun-dodging, and when a pronoun is unavoidable Chick uses "it."

Para Bruin the rubber bear is also from this story! (Baum's thing for rubber strikes again.)

Is this the only Baumian book with a language barrier? John Dough is magically enabled to speak to anyone, but Para Bruin speaks one language, Chick and the other humans speak another, and the Mifkins speak a third.

Unexpectedly serious body horror when John's fingers get eaten off.

The story wraps up in a typical Baumian way: John stumbles into a country (well, two countries; this is the book that Hiland and Loland are from) that needs a new ruler, and the people immediately decide he's a great choice.

Apparently the publishers wanted Baum to firmly establish Chick as male or female by the end. He refused. The last few lines of the book:

"The Records of the Kingdom say very little of Chick's later history, merely mentioning the fact that the King's most valuable assistant was the Head Booleywag, who grew up to be the especial favorite of all the inhabitants of the island. But, curiously enough, the Records fail to state whether the Head Booleywag was a man or a woman."

erinptah: (disney)

Gotta finish this Baum reread, because it's Yuletide season and I may need the canon refreshment for my assignment and/or treats.

The Tin Woodman of Oz -- book 12 -- is a nice low-key novel, heavy on the backstory. Useful plot hook: another random Oz civilian, this time a Winkie boy named Woot, wanders to the Tin Woodman's castle, where Nick Chopper and the Scarecrow treat him to food and backstory. When Woot hears that Nick used to be engaged to a fellow Munchkin before he was rebuilt without a heart, he declares that it's Nick's duty to fulfill his promise and marry the woman (thus making her Empress of the Winkies), even if he doesn't love her.

Bonus: from his self-description, the Tin Woodman is what in modern terms we would call canon aromantic:

"She said she still loved me, but I found that I no longer loved her. My tin body contained no heart, and without a heart no one can love. [...] [T]he Wizard's stock of hearts was low, and he gave me a Kind Heart instead of a Loving Heart, so that I could not love Nimmie Amee any more than I did when I was heartless."

The quest is front-loaded with boys...which is thoroughly plot-relevant, because a girl in the party would have stopped them and said "why are you assuming this woman is still pining after you? She hasn't even seen you for decades. She's probably moved on."

***

Plenty of little continuity drops. Woot used to live near Oogaboo. The Scarecrow has learned poetry at the Woggle-Bug's college. Woot gets lost and falls into a cavern full of dragons, which are clearly the same underground dragons we saw in book 4.

And there's the castle of the Yoop, from book 7! In a mirror/foreshadowing of the characters' main bad assumption, they assume that since the Yoop is locked up, his castle will be empty. Turned out that was only Mr. Yoop -- the home is still occupied by Mrs. Yoop. And she's hella powerful. Like "casually mentions she has Polychrome in a birdcage in her room" powerful.

Poly's temporarily a canary, but she still has magic powers, she just has to do things like pick up a twig and wave it around in her beak.

She turns Nick into an owl. But he's still made of tin! And the Scarecrow gets to be a little bear, stuffed with straw. It's hilarious. (Woot: a green monkey.)

So much meditation on identity, and transformation, and what qualities make you yourself! Since Nick got all his original body parts replaced one at a time, is he really still the same person? If he keeps his memories and personality but happens to be shaped like an owl, does that make him unsuitable for marriage? How about if he's shaped like a man, but only a few inches tall? The others get drawn into the theme with their unwilling transformations, and there's a related sequence where the Scarecrow has to give up his stuffing, so Poly carries him in the form of a bundle of clothes for a while.

...also, a one-off scene with a guy named Tommy Quick-Step, who, after an unfortunate wish, has a really long torso and 20 legs. Insert your own human-centipede jokes here.

***

Our heroes continue walking/flying toward Winkie Country, but now they make a deliberate detour to Jinjur's house. I love that she and the Scarecrow are buddies now.

Luckily, Ozma and Dorothy have been spying on the party via Magic Picture this whole time, so they rendezvous at Jinjur's place to reverse the transformations and say hi. (Along with Toto. Still comfortably using human language, though it's mostly to say things like "Leave me out of your magic, please!")

Ozma appears "about 14 or 15," and Dorothy "much younger." (But only half a head shorter?) This is the book where Baum really doubles down on the "nobody ever ages, really, there are babies in this country who have been babies for thousands of years" version of continuity.

Sure enough, Dorothy: "Do you s'pose Nimmie Amee still loves you, after all these years?" Nick is totally convinced. Ozma says that, well, it can't hurt to go visit her and ask.

Anyway, it turns out Nimmie Amee got a new boyfriend (a soldier, unsubtly named Captain Fyter) not long after Nick broke up with her. The witch tried the same limb-lopping-off trick, and Fyter did the same incremental replacement with tin prosthetics, aaaaaaaand that was what convinced Nimmie Amee to accept a marriage proposal. She has a thing for tin!

But Fyter conveniently got rusted in a rainstorm, so after Nick oils him and hears his backstory, they try to figure out which of them has a better claim to their one-time fiancée.

Woot: "If she's into tin, you're basically interchangeable."
Scarecrow: "Why don't you draw lots for her?"
Polychrome, currently the only girl in the party, eyerolling so hard you can probably see it from space: "No, you idiots, it's up to her who she marries."

Seriously, the gender politics of the whole thing feels way ahead of its time.

***

Massive body horror alert:

In trying to track Nimmie Amee down, the party goes to the tinsmith who made Nick's and Fyter's tin bodies...and find out that he still has their leftover meat parts. Still alive. Most of them in a barrel. Nick finds his own old severed head in a cupboard, and they have the most bizarre conversation.

On top of this, it turns out the tinsmith patched together a bunch of those parts to make a whole new Frankenstinian person. All the "what makes you yourself, anyway?" thematic questions are getting slammed, and hard.

The tin men finally find their old sweetheart living in the mountains. They still expect her to be actively crying over her lost love.

Nope. She's married. The body-horror-chimera guy has been her husband for, like, decades now. And she's not interested in either of the tin guys,

Good going, girl.

On the way home they stop in the Emerald City, and the tin men ask, kinda pathetically, what they should do about all this? Ozma sets them straight with an incredibly patient "look, your ex is happy, and it's really none of your business."

Fyter gets hired as a soldier by Ozma, while Nick and the Scarecrow return home, to get back to bro'ing it up for the next few decades. And the Tin Woodman soothes his ego with the idea that, eh, the Winkies probably didn't want an empress anyway.
erinptah: Cat in christmas lights (christmas)
Hello, prospective future Yuletide writer! Thank you in advance for the fic you are about to embark on. Here's a bunch of information to make it as easy as possible.

Oz books, Home, Fake News )
erinptah: (Default)

Rinkitink in Oz...sure is a book.

This is Baum at peak "desperately trying to be allowed to write non-Oz things." First chapter opens with "look, ravenous fandom, you've seen a map of Oz, right? Okay, zoom out until you've got a view of the surrounding countries. See these islands? We're going there now. Still totally an Oz book, so stay with me! And bring your money."

The eponymous Rinkitink shows up to visit the island nation of Pingaree just in time for it to be invaded by the evil nation next door. The evil islanders kidnap all the locals except Prince Inga, who goes to the rescue, along with Rinkitink and a talking goat.

Things only start to get Ozzy toward the very end, when the evil king and queen try to get Inga off their backs by passing his captive parents on to the Nome Kingdom. And then Dorothy sees the whole thing in the Magic Picture, and deus-ex-machinas a rescue with the help of the Wizard and a basket of eggs.

Wikipedia says Baum wrote most of the story in 1905, before Oz book 3 was published, and you can tell there wasn't a lot of revising. The writing doesn't have the wit and charm that was so good in books 7 and 8. The fantasy countries have the same blandness that dragged down book 9. At this point in the timeline the Nome Kingdom is ruled by Kaliko, but this book was originally written with Ruggedo -- and it's painfully obvious. I bet Baum didn't change anything beyond find-and-replacing the names.

There isn't a single girl in the party, which is grating. And this is the book with the wince-worthy scene about a transformed human being turned back in stages, with one of those stages being a Tottenhot (last seen in book 7).

Entirely skippable.

***

On to Book 11, Lost Princess of Oz, and FINALLY, Baum has accepted his lot in life and gotten into a groove. It's familiar Oz characters with an Oz-centric conflict that we're guaranteed to care about from the first sentence -- Ozma is missing.

Dorothy is the one who confirms Ozma isn't just sleeping in. You see, she's the only one who's always allowed into Ozma's chambers, no matter how early, or late, the hour. Draw your own conclusions.

The kidnapper has also managed to disappear all the MacGuffins that would have made the rescue too easy. The Magic Picture is gone. When the Wizard takes a speedy Sawhorse-back ride all the way to Glinda's castle, he learns that the Magic Book is gone -- and so are all her spellcasting ingredients and equipment -- and, when he gets back, so is his.

Awkwardly, the Magic Belt is still here...but somehow Dorothy has forgotten how to use it. It'll protect her while she's wearing it, and that's all. I wish Baum had at least tried to shoehorn in an excuse. (Maybe it's been so many years that Dorothy's forgotten? Maybe its automatic spell-understanding power has run down, like Tik-Tok when he can only speak nonsense because his thoughts have run down?)

There's a bunch of lovely setting description -- of Ozma's rooms, of Glinda's magic book, of other scenery. Reminiscent of the time in book 6 when Baum slowed down to give us a bunch of national statistics about Oz: we've been here before, but this time he's thinking about it.

***

The B-plot involves an isolated mesa-top community in the Winkie Country, where Cayke the cook's magic diamond-studded dishpan is gone too. She and the Frogman, local respected oracle and literal giant frog, set out to find it.

In general, this is painfully less interesting. Although the way average Ozites react to them is pretty funny:

"Tell me, my good man, have you seen a diamond-studded gold dishpan?"

"No, nor have I seen a copper-plated lobster."

And here's what happens when they stumble into the country of the teddy bears (yeah, it's a thing), get arrested for trespassing, and are brought before the king for sentencing:

"I condemn you to death merely as a matter of form. It sounds quite terrible, and in ten years we shall have forgotten all about it."

So, a few good snappy lines. Too few. Even now that Baum is writing a fresh new plot instead of harvesting earlier manuscripts, he's slid pretty far from the high point of cleverness we got in books 7 and 8.

***

The familiar characters, meanwhile, set off for a manual, boots-on-the-ground search. They split up into four parties to search the four Oz countries; Dorothy's party is the one we follow.

It is, unfortunately, much too big. In spite of the excellent plot-based excuse to split people up, we end up with Dorothy, Betsy, Trot, Button-Bright, the Wizard, Scraps, the Woozy, the Cowardly Lion, Hank the mule, the Sawhorse, and Toto. That's 11 characters! We're doubling up on roles, and there aren't nearly enough good lines to go around.

The distinctions between the American girls have pretty much collapsed. Trot and Betsy never get anything useful or plot-relevant to do that separates them from Dorothy, and their lines are all interchangeable.

Button-Bright isn't much better in the beginning. At least his propensity for getting lost becomes a plot point. (Dorothy scolds him for wandering off when they're on an important mission! She's come so far.)

The Wizard seems to feel pretty useless without his magic, though he does get a few good tool-using moments, recalling his resourcefulness throughout book 4. Would've been nice if this was a more explicit character arc -- from "uh-oh, what do I do without supernatural powers?" to "wait, I'm a clever and resourceful guy, I just have to get my groove back." I mean, this is the man who once took over the country with nothing but bluff, stage magic, and elbow grease.

Scraps is great. As sharply-characterized as ever. Gets to demonstrate that she's just as good at coming up with clever plans as the Scarecrow, though she's more mischievous about rolling them out. When the party gets stymied by an illusion, she's the one who susses it out -- a nice payoff for the time she learned how to deal with illusions in book 7.

The Woozy, Sawhorse, and Hank are, eerily, not much better differentiated than the girls. The Lion isn't much better, though his characteristic cowardice still pops up. Should've only brought one of these, maybe two.

There's a whole chapter when the beasts are discussing what physical features are best, and of course they all have wildly different bodies and capabilities...but each one has exactly the same level of pride in his own appearance, and expresses it in the same way as the next one. There's no individual personality coming through.

Toto manages to stand out, partly because of his relationship with Dorothy, partly because he has a mini-arc about "losing his growl." (You'd think this would be a great opportunity for the Woozy to be sympathetic....)

Apparently Toto has gotten more comfortable talking since his last appearance. He's having whole conversations now, and wasn't communicating nonverbally even before the growl-loss. I guess it's nice that he's already chatty, instead of being forced by circumstances to do something he isn't comfortable with...but this feels like another missed opportunity for a character arc.

***

The most substantial character arc in the book is actually from the other party.

At first the Frogman is hugely-respected in his little corner of Oz, assumed to be wise and thoughtful because he's so unique, and he goes along with this because he likes the attention. He joins Cayke on her quest because he expects to find new people to fawn on him. The indifference of the average Winkie is pretty jarring.

Then they wander past the Truth Pond -- last seen in book 5 -- and the Frogman goes for a splash, only to discover that, whoops, now he can't lie. Maybe not even to himself. He comes clean with Cayke about not being as smart or venerable as he put on...and ends up doing some genuinely heroic things, putting himself in danger to help others, now that he can't just coast along on bluff-based admiration.

***

"Search for Ozma" stumbles into being "search for a magician evil and powerful enough to have stolen Ozma," and the parties converge when they both start aiming for Ugu the Shoemaker. Your standard megalomaniac sorcerer.

Turns out Cayke's magic dishpan has teleporting powers, because why not. Ugu stole that first, used it to zap himself into Glinda's and Ozma's homes to steal their stuff, and then -- when Ozma caught him in the act -- had to hastily kidnap her as an afterthought.

One of the souvenirs from the teddy-bear country is a new MacGuffin: a tiny wind-up bear that can give true answers to any question. Not always specific-enough answers, unfortunately. They ask for Ozma's location, it points them to a hole in the ground not far from Ugu's castle, but all they see when they get there is Button-Bright.

And apparently none of them know how to play Twenty Questions. Or remember a whole lot of their own continuity, because we get lines of speculation like this:

"Perhaps Button-Bright is Ozma." / "And perhaps he isn't! Ozma is a girl, and Button-Bright is a boy."

Yeah, and the last time Ozma was kidnapped, the villain's whole plot was to hide her by transfiguring her into a boy, so your point is...?

Button-Bright also scornfully insists, "Nothing ever enchants ME." Kid, on your first adventure you got turned into a fox-person. Dorothy was there!

You would think, considering that three separate characters in this party were on the expedition to Ev, one of them would remember where the missing Tin Woodman was eventually found, and start turning down Button-Bright's pockets.

(Once the Wizard finally thinks to ask narrowing-down questions, our heroes find Ozma pretty quickly. They recover all the magical tools and ingredients. They even finally track down Cayke's dishpan, and send her home happy.)

***

But listen, all Plot-Enforced Stupidity aside, I love the way this book ends, and here's why:

How do they defeat Ugu? This terrifyingly strong evil wizard? The villain who managed to imprison Princess Ozma, de-power Glinda the Good, and generally get the best of all good magic-users in Oz?

Dorothy beats him in a magical showdown.

She's been secretly practicing with the Magic Belt. ("I transformed the Sawhorse into a potato masher and back again, and the Cowardly Lion into a pussycat and back again.") Now she breaks it out and gets her magical-girl on, complete with an "I'll punish you" speech. Saves the rest of the crew from Ugu's traps, and, with transfiguration power that rivals the Nome King's, turns Ugu himself into a dove. I would make a "he got better" joke here, but...he does not. The very last denouement scene is dove!Ugu asking Dorothy for her forgiveness.

Dorothy Gale has gone from "sweet, simple Kansas child, who was a meek and tearful prisoner for the Wicked Witch of the West" to "most formidable magic-user in all Oz."

And boy, she will wallop you if you mess with her girlfriend.

erinptah: (Default)

Short takeaway: The Sea Fairies is not on par with the Oz books. Its sequel Sky Island can hold its own. The Scarecrow of Oz, as the ninth Oz novel and the third with Trot, is a letdown to both series.

***

Both Trot books start very differently from any of Dorothy's adventures (or Betsy's trope-xeroxing adventure). In The Sea Fairies, Trot and Cap'n Bill are going sailing near their house when some mermaids (that's what "sea fairies" means) show up and invite the humans to take a tour of their undersea kingdom.

So the first half of the book is just a random tour. It isn't even as charming as most of the Oz-related settings. Especially since so much of it is spent on pseudo-scientific explanations of how mermaids work -- none of which are actually any more sensible or satisfying than whatever "mystery" they're trying to explain.

Halfway through the story a Big Bad shows up, but everything about it that might provide some tension gets undercut. He's an evil sea monster!...who has zero power outside his own lair, to the point that he can't even lure our heroes there or send agents to kidnap them, he literally sends them an invitation and they swim right in. He keeps humans lost in shipwrecks to use as slaves!...but they're all unfazed by their state, figuring they were gonna be dead anyway, and this life isn't so bad. One of the slaves is Cap'n Bill's own long-lost brother!...who's been gone for so long that Bill barely remembers him, didn't feel much grief over his disappearance or much joy at their reunion, and there's no mention of this maybe being their cue to embark on a brother-rescuing quest.

Finally a Big Good shows up to defeat the Big Bad, and our heroes go home. The end.

It's notable that we get a lot of Trot's real-world life and family history.

***

Both books are more tied to real-world concerns than the Oz books get. With Dorothy, we got bits and pieces of her Kansas backstory over the various books; with Betsy, we get nothing at all. With Trot, we get a bunch of family history right off the bat.

I appreciate Cap'n Bill. He's practical, in a way that Baum's books don't often call for -- in the next book he knocks together a seat in his workshop, to make a magic umbrella into a viable flying machine for three.

And his contrariness and skepticism (not "this magic thing can't be real", but "I don't trust this magic thing to be safe")...it never pans out, everything in these books is either Obviously Good or Obviously Bad, but it's nice to see a different character type.

As for Trot...

...okay, here's the thing: Trot is mean.

Dorothy in her later appearances can be very definite about what's proper and what's not (see: insisting on renaming Bill to Billina), but with the exception of that one bizarre scene in Bunbury, she isn't rude. Trot regularly tells people to their faces how horrid they are. Look, here's her first meeting with the Big Bad from Sea Fairies:

"Well," said he, "do you not find me the most hateful creature you have ever beheld?"

The queen refrained from answering, but Trot said promptly, "We do. Nothing could be more horrider or more disgustin' than you are, it seems to me."

"Very good, very good indeed," declared the monster, lifting his lashes to flash his glowing eyes upon them.

And, sure, that guy's evil (and seems to be getting off on the insults anyway), but here she is with a completely random innocent octopus:

"Well, are we not friends, then?" asked the Octopus in an airy tone of voice.

"I think not," said the little girl. "Octopuses are horrid creatures."

"OctoPI, if you please; octoPI," said the monster with a laugh.

"I don't see any pie that pleases me," replied Trot, beginning to get angry.

"OctoPUS means one of us; two or more are called octoPI," remarked the creature, as if correcting her speech.

"I suppose a lot of you would be a whole bakery!" she said scornfully. [...]

"Let's go," said Trot. "I don't like to 'sociate with octopuses."

"OctoPI," said the creature, again correcting her.

"You're jus' as horrid whether you're puses or pies," she declared.

(In a joke that will fly right over the heads of any kid not born in the era, it turns out she's seen the contemporary political cartoons where the big trusts like Standard Oil are represented as octopi.)

I control-F'd back through the Gutenberg texts of the earlier books. Betsy never uses the word "horrid." Dorothy uses it a few times to refer to the Deadly Desert; Eureka's behavior on meeting Billina is "horrid of you"; and she uses it twice for Princess Langwidere, prompted by the fact that Langwidere first insults her and her friends, then tries to chop off her head, then locks her in a tower until she agrees to have her head chopped off. Clearly worse than "being an octopus."

Sometimes that kind of shameless certainty goes to good places. At the end of Sky Island, Trot shuts down the blue country's system of capitol punishment, and holds to it even when her new regent wants to chop just a few more people in half, come on, not even just the worst one?

But yeah, in general, she distinguishes herself from Dorothy and Betsy by being distinctively unpleasant.

***

Baum's writing is much-improved with book 2. It kicks off when Button-Bright drops in -- he's definitely grown, he's speaking in complete sentences now, and knows his own name and everything! -- via magic umbrella. Cap'n Bill rigs up that wooden seat, and they go for some flights, only to get stuck for a while on the eponymous Sky Island.

Apparently some kinds of magic work in the non-fairy country of America: Button-Bright's umbrella took him to a couple of different US cities before they hit the island. He and Trot use it for a morning jaunt down to the village to pick up some sewing supplies, for crying out loud.

The fantasy settings, once we get there, have the sense of fun and creativity that I expect from the Oz books. Sky Island has a pink half and a blue half, each with its own politics, customs, magical weirdnesses, and total commitment to color scheme. I was briefly excited to hear that, in the blue country, the kings are elected -- but no, when the people vote, they have to vote for whoever the king told them to. Whoops.

Meanwhile, in the pink country, the ruler is determined by...who has the lightest skin. Holy unfortunate implications, Batman.

Since this island is permanently located in the clouds, we finally get an encounter with Polychrome that doesn't involve her getting lost on the ground. And this book is officially in the Oz continuity! I wasn't sure about the relative timing, until Polychrome says cheerfully that she recognizes Button-Bright because they last saw each other in Oz.

Turns out Poly can be an ad-hoc fairy legal scholar. Neat.

By the end of the book, Trot is the new Queen of the pink country, and the Boss of the blue country. But she never considers staying -- she likes her home life in California, and she's been gone for like a week now, so her mom is probably panicking. She leaves both countries in the hands of responsible regents, and little party heads home.

***

The Scarecrow of Oz starts more like a traditional Oz book. Our heroes are sucked into a whirlpool, come out in a cave, and set off to find their way home.

The preface explains that this book is Baum's response to getting tons of letters imploring him to send Trot and Cap'n Bill to Oz. So, as if he's just trying to be contrary, he washes them up on the shores of Mo. And has them meet a character who chides them for not having heard of the place.

Continuity! The place still rains lemonade, snows popcorn, and has perfume-scented wind. And you can see the advancement in Baum's skill, as he doesn't just run through a list of junk-food-related weirdnesses, but reveals them naturally in response to a weather event happening, or Trot asking something.

They also bump into Button-Bright again. He's a lot more talky than in his first Oz appearance, but it feels like he's regressed from Sky Island. He's back to asking "what's x?" questions about random things that come up -- in Road To Oz, that was most of his vocabulary -- and saying rude and cranky things in general.

***

The Ozsolation has gone from "super dramatic" to "totally ineffectual." Our heroes bumble into Oz exactly the same way so many other outsiders have: by flying over the place and needing to land.

Technically they bumble into Jinxland, which is in an isolated and cut-off bit of Quadling Country. I completely believe the theory that Baum didn't write it to be part of Oz at all, and only retconned it in after-the-fact.

The writing in general feels like a throwback. None of the sharp wit from the last couple of books. Stock plot about an evil king trying to marry his princess niece off to an also-evil vizier, even though she loves a humble servant, who is conveniently also a prince. Lots of unsubtle punny names. The evil king is named King Krewel, fercryinoutloud.

The drama relies on the throne needing a successor, but nobody in Oz is supposed to die, so Baum has to come up with multiple awkward excuses to get rid of previous kings for good. Oh, and there are a bunch of active witches! With the excuse that they're so cut-off and so distant from the Emerald City that they can get away with it, even though they're right in Glinda's back yard, and her Magic Book means she knows exactly what they're up to.

We're in chapter 13 of 24 before the Scarecrow finally shows up.

With a bit of help from deus ex Glinda, they overthrow the evil vizier, undo some wicked witchcraft, and install the princess niece on the throne. The Scarecrow is briefly King of Jinxland before surrendering the throne to the rightful heir after a bit of relevant magic is lifted. Seems to be a talent of his.

***

Meanwhile: Dorothy, Betsy, and Ozma have been watching this whole adventure in the Magic Picture. It's like their very own privacy-invading reality TV.

Describes Betsy as a "shy little thing" who still isn't used to the splendor of Oz (in contrast to Dorothy, who's perfectly at home with it). She didn't seem all that shy in the last book. Nervous in strange places sometimes, but she strikes up conversations pretty easily, and rode Hank straight into the Nome King's palace without any self-consciousness. (Retroactive attempt to make them more distinct? I can dig it.)

Anyway: they decide to have Trot and Cap'n Bill stay in Oz forever.

Remember the whole cautious discussion Ozma had about whether it would be too much to extend that same invite to Betsy and Shaggy's brother, even knowing those two had no place to go? Yeah, that's no longer a thing. They don't even check whether Trot and Cap'n Bill want to live here before deciding to make the offer.

There's also a reference to Dorothy being the one who introduced Ozma to the Hungry Tiger, so, wow, Baum is just forgetting continuity right and left here.

***

It's such a shambles, you guys.

My impression of Trot from back when I had only read this book was "another generic not-Dorothy," and no wonder! All her distinctive characterization is limited to the first two books. She's way more generic in this one.

She's not noticeably mean. Just a little callous. (When the princess is lamenting that she'll never be able to marry the humble servant, Trot's idea of comfort is "Well, never mind; Pon isn't any great shakes, anyhow, seems to me. There are lots of other people you can love.")

She suddenly has a "grave and serious little face." That's never been a Trot thing! You know what it is? A classic Dorothy thing.

Dorothy assumes Trot will be intimidated by the glamour of the Emerald City. Trot, honored guest of the Queen of the Mermaids, herself the Queen of Sky Island! But sure enough -- in this book, she is. Intimidated by Glinda, too. The girl who had no problem insulting a murderous sea monster to its face, and now she literally needs to be handheld through meeting the sorceress.

You'd think she would've pulled rank as Queen when she and Cap'n Bill were the ones trying to intimidate King Krewel, but no.

There's the obligatory scene with the new arrivals having dinner with a bunch of Oz standbys. Trot and Cap'n Bill are astonished by the talking animals. As if they just dropped straight into Oz from America, and hadn't extensively toured two other realms with talking animals beforehand!

In the other books, these meetings are always the setup for some charming character interactions -- like Jim the Cab-Horse's huffy rivalry with the Sawhorse, or Aunt Em trying to hairy-eyeball the Cowardly Lion into submission. Here, it's just a boilerplate list of characters, and the authorial announcement that suddenly Trot feels like she's Friends With Them All.

...and then they decide to stay. On top of all the Oz-related reasons why this is weird, how does it make sense on Trot's side? She has loving parents! Who are also Cap'n Bill's dear friends. There's no struggle over how to handle that, not even a sidenote about them tragically dying offscreen. They're just...forgotten.

I can't imagine this being satisfying for all those eager letter-writing Trot fans.

Would've been a lot more satisfying as an Oz book, too, if Trot's interactions with Oz had been informed by her own unique history of fairy-country exploration. Instead, it just becomes yet another rehash of what we got in the last book with Betsy -- and this time, it isn't fresh or witty, just cheap and tired.
erinptah: (Default)
There's a Baum-penned book of Oz short stories that came out between books 7 and 8. I'm not sure whether Little Wizard Stories of Oz is objectively better than the stories of Mo, or just feels more grounded because it uses characters we already know...either way, it's a cute roundup of character moments and worldbuilding details that might not have fit into any of the larger adventures.

And it shows that Baum hates coming up with titles as much as the rest of us.

The Cowardly Lion and the Hungry Tiger: in which we learn that Oz has an afternoon siesta! The Lion and the Tiger resolve to finally act on their natural "tearing a person apart" and "eating a fat baby" instincts, but when they head out into the street, everybody's napping.

Also: when Ozma is holding court, Dorothy habitually sits at her feet. Um. That setup doesn't say "auxiliary princess" so much as "lounging courtesan." (I like it.)

Little Dorothy and Toto: probably the backstory of how Dorothy got cured of her getting-lost habit between books 6 and 7. The Wizard keeps telling her that he's worried she'll get in real trouble, and when that doesn't sink in, he stages an object lesson: disguising himself as a shape-changing imp who captures her and forces her to wash dishes.

He kinda learns a lesson himself, when he has to cut the charade short because Toto nearly eats him.

At one point Toto looks at a warning sign "so seriously that Dorothy almost believed he could read it." One of several bits of serious foreshadowing that he's secretly just as language-enabled as all the other mundane animals who have visited Oz.

Tik-Tok and the Nome King: in which it turns out that non-Oz fairy countries have currencies: after the king smashes Tik-Tok and Kaliko fixes him, Kaliko's wages are raised by "one specto a year."

This is really hard to place in the timeline. The fact that Tik-Tok leaves Oz doesn't mean it's pre-Ozsolation; by book 8 some major exceptions have been carved out. The King is intimidated by Ozma and scared of the consequences of breaking one of her things, which doesn't jive with his angry, revenge-seeking mindset between books 3 and 6...so I guess it's sometime during the timeskip, while he's still reconstructing the events he can't remember, and figuring out that Ozma scares him.

Ozma and the Little Wizard: in which we learn that Ozma doesn't just hang out on the throne, but tours the country to do problem-solving in person.

Jack Pumpkinhead and the Sawhorse: more Ozma problem-solving, this time through sending agents. Jack engages in diplomacy with the King of the Squirrels, only to get his head smashed with a branch. It's like a mashup of that scene with Kronk intoning "Squeak squeakerson squeak squeak," and the head-exploding scene from Scanners.

The Scarecrow and the Tin Woodman: in which these two queer characters take a romantic boat ride together, and get so wrapped up in each other that they crash into a rock because they're not paying attention. I'm not even kidding, that's it, that's the plot.

***

On to book 8! Tik-Tok of Oz is titled in the fine tradition of "pick one random character who appears in the story, and name the book after them." It starts in one of Oz's mini-countries: Oogaboo, a tiny mountain kingdom in Winkie Country. And by "tiny" I mean: "18 men, 27 women and 44 children."

Baum's writing is on-point in this book. Strong multi-level plot, snappy humor. Oogaboo "had a royal family of their own. Not especially to rule over them; just as a matter of pride" -- and their Queen Ann Soforth (who I always imagined as effectively college-age, immortality aside) gets so frustrated that she decides to head out and conquer the world.

She ropes 17 of the nation's 18 adult males into her Army -- that's 16 officers and 1 private soldier. Much less capable than General Jinjur's Army of Revolt, to say nothing of General Guph's collection of horrors...but, admittedly, a match for the Royal Army of Oz, at least since Ozma promoted their private.

Thing is, the Emerald City is so over being conquered. Glinda sees the Army of Oogaboo coming, and teleports them out of Oz long before they have any idea what they're doing.

Meanwhile, Shaggy is looking for his brother. The Shaggy Man really is Baum's favorite, isn't he? I remembered him being introduced in book 5, and his quest to save his brother here, but had forgotten how Baum stuck him in the party in both of the novels in between, too. He's like wallpaper. Shaggy wallpaper.

This plot thread racks up a party with remarkable efficiency. Oklahoma girl Betsy Bobbin gets shipwrecked with Hank the donkey, and runs into the Shaggy Man. A detour into the eerily misogynistic Rose Kingdom has them walk out with a Rose Princess (as in book 4, our heroes pick the ripe ruler; but these flowers want to be ruled by a king, so they kick her out). They meet up with Polychrome, lost from the rainbow again -- weirdly, she and Shaggy both act like they've never met before. Then they yank Tik-Tok out of a well!

I was going to say "maybe this is Tik-Tok on the way back from being fixed by Kaliko," but no, he was sent by Ozma to help on the quest. One wonders why Ozma didn't teleport him directly to Shaggy's side. Or, even better, why she doesn't teleport them all into the same room as Shaggy's brother...but I digress.

Asked how to get to the Nome Kingdom: "The best way is to walk," said Tik-Tok. "We might crawl, or jump, or roll o-ver and o-ver until we get there; but the best way is to walk." I told you this one was funny.

***

Some thoughts on Betsy. Let's face it, she's awfully hard to distinguish from Dorothy at times -- plucky young girl from the US who gets shipwrecked in a fairy country with a stalwart animal companion. Ozma even lampshades it toward the end, telling Dorothy that Betsy got shipwrecked "in much the same way you did."

Some differences: She throws herself into adventure for its own sake, with no wistful thoughts of returning to home or family -- in the end she says she has no home to go back to. (We never get that backstory.) It probably helps her adjustment that she's read some of the Oz books. Not enough to know the Shaggy Man on sight, but she's all impressed that he's friends with Dorothy and Ozma.

Dorothy takes weird things in stride, befitting someone whose first fairy adventure happened when she was really little. She's used to assuming that whatever's going on is normal. Betsy asks a lot of questions -- even about things that are normal by mundane-world standards, like "why are all tubes hollow?"

And she's nervous about being sent off to sleep alone in a strange place. Dorothy -- well, she usually has Toto at her side, but she took it pretty easily in book 3 when Langwidere took away Billina and Tik-Tok before locking her in a tower. Betsy is a welcomed guest when the party lands in Tititi-Hoochoo's country, and she's still anxious about being alone for the night, enough that they end up sending Polychrome with her.

***

Okay, backing up: The two quests crash together; Shaggy suggests that Ann can conquer the Nomes while he's rescuing his brother. Their destinies are further entwined when Private Files quits -- he refuses Ann's orders to take the girls captive -- and Tik-Tok obligingl lets himself get recruited to be the new Army of Oogaboo.

Ruggedo may no longer have the Magic Belt, but he still knows a lot of spells and controls a lot of useful equipment. When he spots the would-be invaders, he arranges to drop them down a hole to a fairy country on the far side of the earth. (It's even pseudo-Chinese. Their formal wear is cheongsams with embroidered dragons!)

All this is very illegal. Kaliko, hearing the plan, sneaks off to his room and starts writing letters of recommendation for himself.

("I hate mortals more than I hate catnip tea!" You take a lot of that, Ruggedo...?)

Paralleling the army that's all officers except for one private, this country is all Kings and Queens with one Private Citizen: Tititi-Hoochoo (I didn't say it was good pseudo-Chinese), who runs the place. A counterpoint to the last book's legal ideas: "It is wise to ignore laws when they conflict with justice." Our heroes have broken the law, but it was the Nome King's fault, so they get sent back to deliver justice.

Along with a dragon!

Serious horror when Kaliko explains how he learned to fear dragons. Another Nome had been torn to pieces by a dragon, you see, and since in fairy countries nobody dies...Kaliko found a chunk of head. That could talk.

I wonder how these dragons relate to the ones whose cavern Dorothy and company snuck through in book 4. For that matter, how do all those underground countries compare with the Nome Kingdom? I'm inclined to believe they're even deeper -- they have no contact with the surface, and the Nomes don't show any sign of knowing about civilizations like the Valley of Vo. (Not to be confused with the Valley of Mo.)

***

Ruggedo gets insta-smitten with Polychrome, Hades-Persephone style. It's actually kinda cute. Imploring her to stay: "You shall be my daughter or my wife or my aunt or grandmother—whichever you like." (Poly: "Are you sure he hasn’t seen the Love Magnet?")

The dragon came prepared. By the time the dust has settled, Ruggedo has been depowered and dethroned (Kaliko gets his place!); Shaggy has found his brother; and the Army of Oogaboo is sick and tired of conquering and just wants to go home.

Honestly, there's something shady about Shaggy's quest. He claims not to remember what his brother looks like. Okay, he left home several decades ago, when the brother was much younger...but when asked the guy's name, he hesitates. And indeed, only ever addresses the man as "Brother" (while introducing himself as "Shaggy").

And of course we'll never see the guy again (the brother; I do expect plenty more Shaggy) in any future books. What was really up with these two? We'll never know.

In an interesting complication, the characters' haste in de-powering Ruggedo comes back to bite them. Sure, he deserved the punishment, but he'd put a curse on Shaggy's brother, and no longer has the power to undo it. Instead the characters have to figure it out through trial and error. Can't remember any other children's fantasy fiction that pulls something quite like it.

***

Poly confirmed to be thousands of years old!

The Magic Picture is in a radium frame. Oh geez.

The Wizard invented the cell phone! But didn't include a mechanism for calling anyone. You just have to hope that you and the other person manage to pick up your handhelds at the same time.

The dragon goes home, the Nome Kingdom adjusts, and the rest of the characters get teleported back to Oz in batches. There's no legal immigration process since the Ozsolation, and Betsy, Hank, and Shaggy's brother never got their visas, but obviously in the end they get royal approval to stay.

In the latest edition of I Swear I Am Not Making This Gay Up:
“Well,” said Dorothy, “as far as Betsy and Hank are concerned, I’d like to have them here in Oz. It would be such fun to have a girl playmate of my own age, you see. And Hank is such a dear little mule!”

Ozma laughed at the wistful expression in the girl’s eyes, and then she drew Dorothy to her and kissed her.“Am I not your friend and playmate?” she asked.

Dorothy flushed.

“You know how dearly I love you, Ozma!” she cried. “But you’re so busy ruling all this Land of Oz that we can’t always be together.”

Mmmyep.

Dorothy thinks of Betsy as "her own age," though Betsy is about 12 and Dorothy has been in Oz at least a couple decades by now. Betsy and Dorothy are about the same height; Ozma is about half a head taller.

And then there's a brewing fight in the stables (over "who is the sweetest and dearest girl in the world," with Hank on Betsy's side, the Sawhorse championing Ozma, and the Lion and Tiger adamant that it's Dorothy) -- which the three heroines interrupt, Ozma standing in the doorway with a mortal girl on each arm. Like a boss.

Finally: this is the book where it comes out that Toto can talk! He just doesn't want to, okay. Stop invalidating Toto's life choices with your anthropocentric communication demands. (I kid, I kid. It's good he told Dorothy, even if he never says another word since.)

***

Programming note: the next Oz book has also been called "the third Trot and Cap'n Bill book", so I'm listening to the first two of those (The Sea Fairies and Sky Island) first. In case anyone has been reading along, join me on my detour.
erinptah: (Default)

Took a detour in the Oz readthrough to check out The Magical Monarch of Mo. (Originally released before The Wonderful Wizard of Oz, then re-released with a matching title in an attempt to capture the same sales magic.)

It's...quantifiably not as good. And that's not just the non-Oz location (3/7 of the books so far have spent the bulk of their time touring other settings) or the lack of familiar characters (scroll down for how much I love Scraps and Ojo). It's a series of short stories, only loosely interrelated, so you don't get any of the characters developed enough to be invested in them. The writing style is much more telling than showing. Far too many of the names are cheesy puns. (A villain named Scowleyow, a thoughtful prince named Thinkabit, a chatty courtier named Nuphsed. I mean, it's not that a name like Jellia Jamb is all that morally superior to Bredenbutta, but in Oz it isn't the only kind of name.)

And it sure doesn't help that you've got princesses being married off as rewards in the very first story. That would never happen with an Oz princess! Nobody would even try.

Surprisingly, the Monarch doesn't show up at Ozma's birthday party. The book is relevant now because one of the Mo citizens, the Wise Donkey, makes a cameo in Oz book 7. He was visiting when the cutoff from the rest of the world happened, and has been stranded there ever since. At least he's gotten comfortable! And made a friend, the Foolish Owl. Maybe they were destined to meet all along.

***

And so, back to Oz! Book 7 -- The Patchwork Girl of Oz -- my childhood favorite, and one of the biggest reasons I'm glad life didn't let Baum get away with stopping at 6.

We've skipped into the future. And I mean waaay in the future. Back in book 6, Billina introduced Dorothy to her eleven children. Here, there's a mention that she's hatched "about seven thousand chicks."

If she's kept up her one-egg-per-day rate as established in book 3, that means it's been almost 7,000 days in-universe -- or, a little over 19 years -- since the last book.

Ozma has been ruling for two decades! Dorothy still looks like a kid, but chronologically she's old enough to drink, drive, and vote! (Hopefully not all at the same time.)

And the cool thing is...we can kinda see it. Our heroes make it to the Emerald City about halfway through their quest, and come away with Dorothy and a couple of others added to the party -- and she really does seem more mature, comfortably established as a young-adult Ozian citizen. She breaks out some clever diplomacy to help broker a peace between two warring towns. She invokes her rank as princess and her closeness with Ozma to get some favors, assuring the citizens that they'll be paid back. She doesn't wander off once!

***

But let's talk about the people she helps. This book the first non-Dorothy protagonist since book 2, and the first (and only?) protagonist who's a completely average Ozian child.

Ojo lives in isolation in the mountains of Munchkinland, with his Unc Nunkie, some trees, and not a lot of food. They stop in to visit the Crooked Magician, who's working on some Powder of Life -- the same guy referenced back in book 2, now all expanded and fleshed-out. Worldbuilding!

Which is not to say there aren't the usual continuity holes. There are references to how nobody dies in Oz and references to past deaths, as well as things the characters are unable to do because it might kill something. And why exactly does Ojo live with his uncle, instead of his parents? Did they die?

The Magician brings the Patchwork Girl to life, but a magical mishap turns his wife and Ojo's uncle into marble statues. The spell to reverse the enchantment needs a list of obscure ingredients, which Ojo and the Patchwork Girl set out to collect, seeing lots of random Ozian oddities and picking up an ever-changing party along the way.

Seriously, Ojo is such a great protagonist. More well-rounded than a lot of these characters, including, dare I say it, first-book Dorothy. He takes a lot of initiative, partly because his uncle rarely says more than one word in a row, meaning that Ojo does a ton of talking to fill things in.

Being raised in isolation means he's out-of-step with the national mainstream -- I'm not gonna say feral, but he's awkwardly socialized, and you can see it in the way he bristles and digs in his heels when faced with a law or a social rule he doesn't want to follow. And he's so prone to self-blame, especially when he picks up the epithet "Ojo the Unlucky" -- any time something on the quest goes wrong, he blames himself and his presence for jinxing anyone who tries to help him.

At the start of the book, he's told he's "unlucky" on account of living in such a lonely place and not having much to eat. Towards the end, he's thought up a bunch of extra reasons to see himself as not just a victim of bad luck but its source, including random details like being born on Friday the 13th. It's a good thing he has friends and allies to talk him out of it.

***

His closest and truest friend is the Patchwork Girl herself, who is also so great, you guys.

Dances, and makes up rhymes, and has even more resistance than Ojo to things like laws and dignity. But when her brains were originally mixed they had an overdose of cleverness, and that shows, too. She's the one who starts the ad-hoc diplomacy that Dorothy finishes! When Ojo gets into legal trouble, she figures out what he's done...and independently invents the concept of "hiding evidence."

And, okay, here's a thing: Scraps is created to be a servant...so she's made out of a multicolored bed-quilt, with the intention that the embarrassment of not being a nice respectable Munchkin blue will keep her in her place as a second-class citizen. Once she's brought to life, she immediately decides, screw that, she's going to love and celebrate her unique rainbow self.

Gee, I wonder why kid!me would have glommed on to this book.

***

Science marches on: our heroes spend some time in an underground community which is lit/decorated entirely with a glowing material they dig out of the mines. And it's...radium.

Hopefully that means magical fairyland radium which does not give the entire species radiation poisoning.

Social awareness marches on: this is the book starring the Tottenhots, which are based on a caricature of African people and exactly as unfortunate as they sound. Some later publications of the book have skipped that passage entirely, which I think is fair. You could refurbish them into just one more innocently-weird fairyland subculture by changing the name and tweaking a few details, but then you have the problem of how to make the result authentically Ozzy without Baum around to consult.

***

But let's get to the really big thing about this book, much as I love it...

People love to write dark, dystopian versions of Oz. And they make up reasons why the country is Secretly Not As Nice As It Seems. Wicked came up with animal oppression. Dorothy Must Die goes with "everyone is forced to be happy" plus some magic-draining and some sadistic torture.

The thing is, it would be so easy to write a dark Oz that's based on actual canon problems in Oz. And those are on full display in book 7.

From the beginning we get reminded that Ozma has made it illegal to do magic, unless you're on a "personal friends of hers" exception list. (Glinda and the Wizard. That's it.) The Crooked Magician reasons that he should be in the clear because he's only doing it for his own personal use, but that doesn't fly when the news gets to the Emerald City, and in the end he's forcibly de-magicked.

One of the ingredients for the marble-curing spell is a six-leaved clover, which are illegal to pick. This is Ojo's big dramatic clash with the law: he picks one on the way to the Emerald City. When they get to the gates...he's promptly arrested, and put in prison, long before anyone tells him what law he's accused of breaking.

To "save Ojo the embarrassment" of being seen as a prisoner, he gets led through the streets in a "prisoner's robe." It's...a sheet with a couple of eye-holes cut in it. How much more conspicuous can you get? It hides his identity but makes him much more of an object of shame and judgment than if he was just walking like a normal person who happens to take walks with the Soldier with the Green Whiskers.

Oh, and there's a constant refrain about how shocking this is, because Nobody Has Ever broken a law of Oz before. It's pure propaganda. The whole reason the "no picking six-leaved clovers" law was created in the first place was because they're a common spell ingredient, and Ozma was trying to make it harder for people to...break the law about "no practicing unauthorized magic."

And that's not even touching on the fact that a female character gets lobotomized for being too haughty and disagreeable. Guys, the Glass Cat was great. In the first leg of the journey -- when it was just her, Scraps, and Ojo -- she was the protective adult of the group. And no matter how haughty she got about her pink brains (you can see 'em work!), it's not as if she out-bragged the Scarecrow.

Seriously, this has all the groundwork for a canon-compliant dark series about an unelected monarch running an oppressive propaganda-fueled police state. Where's that Oz novel, huh? I don't want to write it, but I sure would like to read it.
erinptah: There is only one ship on Doctor Who. (doctor who)

We're six books in, at The Emerald City of Oz, and this is the first time we get a physical description of Dorothy. She has "a round rosy face and earnest eyes."

Also: suddenly, Ozian statistics! The Emerald City has 9,654 buildings, with 57,318 citizens. All the land around it, all the way to the Deadly Desert, is rural/farming country -- no other cities. Total population is "more than half a million people."

So, Oz is about as populous as Luxembourg. Or, alternately, as populous as Albuquerque.

---

Seriously, though, this is the book that set my mental standard for all magical fantasy worlds that exist in parallel for our own.

There's trouble at the Gale farm. They've been having money problems for a while, thanks to that "Uncle Henry getting very sick" problem from the background of books 3-4, and the even-earlier problem of "our whole house got blown away in a tornado." (Continuity!) Henry and Aunt Em have always kinda assumed Dorothy's stories are just vivid dreams, plus an active imagination...but now, when they're about to lose the farm, they sit her down and say, "look, is there any chance you could go live with your magical friends? We're still not sure they're real, but we're kinda hoping."

To which Dorothy is all "oh, yeah, Ozma's invited me to move in with her a bunch of times! I'll signal her this afternoon."

And a day or two after that, Ozma goes on to Magic-Belt this poor old couple from the middle of their chores to the middle of her royal throne room. (Dorothy tried to advocate for finding a nice quiet place out back to have them appear, but Ozma shut that down, because she's a Princess and is going to do this the Princess Way.)

The scene where they run into the Cowardly Lion in a corridor is worth the price of admission all on its own. (Aunt Em tries to intimidate him by staring him down! I'm guessing Dorothy is a niece from her side of the family.)

---

Aside from these excellent bits, the rest of the action is...fine. It's the first book -- maybe the only one? -- where we follow two narratives. Other books have jumped between POVs when the party gets temporarily split up (Tip falling off the Sawhorse and getting left behind; Billina nesting under the Nome King's throne while the others get stashed in guest suites), but here we keep switching between Dorothy and company on the one hand, and, on the other, the Nomes who are planning an attack on Oz.

General Guph recruits allies in the classic one-two-three fairytale structure, working out the rewards for each group. The last and scariest chieftain is so powerful that his only viable sales pitch is "look, I'm a dick, you're a dick, let's go be dicks to Oz together."

Henry and Em, meanwhile, get a more disorganized tour of random cute Ozian settings. Accompanied by the Wizard (who cites his former travel experience as "Europe and Ireland") and the Shaggy Man ("I've been to Mexico and Boston and many other foreign countries").

Eventually Ozma figures out that there's an invasion force digging a tunnel towards Oz under the desert, so our heroes re-converge at the Emerald City to meet their fate together. After they successfully de-power the villains, they decide the only way to keep Oz safe in the future is to build a wall and make the Nomes pay for it.

...I mean, to have Glinda make Oz invisible and un-contactable to anyone in the outside world.

---

This seems like as good a time as any to complain about these books' protagonist-centered morality. Don't know if I thought about it much on previous reads, but it's really standing out this time around.

Mild example: the the Woggle-Bug, who's supposed to be pretty pompous and obnoxious, gets chastised in book 2 for making puns. (To the point where the Scarecrow casts doubt on the value of his brains, and the Tin Woodman -- the character so soft-hearted, he cries after accidentally stepping on an ant -- "twirled his gleaming axe so carelessly that the Woggle-Bug looked frightened.") But when sympathetic characters -- say, the Wizard post-redemption -- do the same thing, nobody blinks. And the narrative itself indulges in some shameless pun blitzes in book 6.

This is also the book where a hungry Dorothy wanders into the town of Bunbury, where everything is edible. (I do love that, even when she's in Oz, Dorothy can't help but wander off and get lost.) A couple of families generously donate some possessions for her breakfast. Then Toto eats some of the citizens...and Dorothy scolds the town for being too stingy, and says she's been "kind" to only eat their "old rubbish." What.

And, of course, the ending. Which we're supposed to think is a good idea mostly because Ozma had it. What about that triumphant birthday party full of distinguished foreign guests? -- not gonna happen again. Wasn't their diplomatic relationship with Ev a good thing? -- don't think about it. Really, nobody else from the US should be allowed to visit? -- really.

Sure, Dorothy (and her family, and the Wizard, and the Shaggy Man, and Billina, and Eureka...) are welcome to be here, even to become permanent citizens of Oz...but, y'know, they're the Good Ones.

Long story short, there are a lot of reasons I'm glad this plot twist didn't stick.

erinptah: Madoka and Homura (madoka)

Even knowing what it actually means in context, I get a smile every time these books go on about Oz being "full of queer personages."

~*~*~*~

Here's something I didn't think about until I listened to book 3 (Ozma of Oz) and book 4 (Dorothy and the Wizard in Oz) back-to-back:

Book 3: Dorothy's adventure starts when she gets swept off a boat, which she's on because she's in the middle of a boat trip with Uncle Henry.

Book 4: Dorothy's adventure starts when she falls into the ground during a California earthquake, where she is because she's traveling back to Kansas from the same trip.

She's gone on vacation once here, and gotten sidetracked for magical adventures on both ends of the journey. Henry and Em must be thinking "good lord, kiddo, you can't travel anywhere without mysteriously vanishing along the way, can you?"

(Of course, in the next book she's walking down a normal Kansas dirt road when it goes all magical. Can't win.)

~*~*~*~

And another thing! During this mundane-world vacation (it's a trip to Australia, which is supposed to be good for Uncle Henry's health), Dorothy and Henry meet "some friends." They're never described in any detail, we just know Dorothy is traveling alone at the start of Book 4 because her uncle went on ahead, while she stayed with these friends for a few days.

In San Francisco.

This book was published in 1908. The history of the SF gay scene goes back pre-1900, with its firs "notorious" gay bar founded in...1908.

I'm not saying Dorothy definitely hung out with cool grown-up lesbian mentors in San Francisco, I'm just saying...historically speaking, it's a serious possibility.

~*~*~*~

Okay, getting back to the (non-figurative) fairy-country content here...

Book 4 marks a huge shift for the series, in that it's a really blatant case of "wow, no overarching plot here at all, they're just wandering from set piece to set piece until the author gets bored."

Of the previous volumes, Book 3 had the most cohesive plot, without any random detours. This one is all detour. Then they hit a dead end -- literally, they get stuck in a cave with no way out! -- and Dorothy signals Ozma to teleport them safely to Oz. Princess ex machina.

Book 5 (The Road to Oz) is The One Where Everyone Gets Genre-Savvy.

When things initially go weird, Dorothy's reaction is "eh, this happens a lot, I'll probably end up in Oz eventually." And then she literally adds "Uncle Henry and Aunt Em have told me they're used to this by now, so they won't be too worried." Her party keeps running into magical towns where the leaders say "oh, hey, it's the famous Dorothy! We've read about you."

And when they finally make it to the Emerald City, Ozma reveals she's the one who started their journey by making things go weird in the first place. Sure, she could've just transported Dorothy instantly to the palace, but apparently she thought Dorothy would have more fun getting there via adventure.

What a good girlfriend.

I mean, good platonic friend.

Everything about Ozma attracted one, and she inspired love and the sweetest affection rather than awe or ordinary admiration. Dorothy threw her arms around her little friend and hugged and kissed her rapturously.

I mean, good platonic friend with rapturous kissing that I am going to sit here and enjoy no matter how Baum meant it.

~*~*~*~

Speaking of Baum, the poor guy's author's-notes get a little more strained with every book. "Welp, the children keep asking for Oz so I'm giving them more Oz, the little tyrants, haha! No really, I love children and only want to make them happy, aaaaand apparently what makes them happy is not buying any of my other books."

He really pushes it in book 5, where the big glittery finale of book 5 is Ozma's birthday -- involving a fifty-cameo pileup referencing every non-Oz book Baum had written. It...did not help their sales the way he was hoping for. (You know what I would have read? A spinoff series about Ev. We spend time there in book 3, see the royals as cameos in book 5, and then never visit the place again. Why didn't you ever write that, L. Frank?)

Honestly, I've read a lot of Baum's non-Oz books, and none of them clicked the way the Oz ones did. But it's been long enough that I couldn't tell you why. Maybe that'll be the next re-listening project.
erinptah: (Default)

Latest relief for my long work day: an epic re-listen of the Oz books -- all fifteen of Baum's. (Librivox has free recordings of the whole set!)

The inspiration to do this was kicked off after listening to the unsubtly-titled Dorothy Must Die, one of the endless Darker And Edgier modern Oz fan-sequels. The premise of this one: an adult Dorothy came back to Oz, went grimdark along with her friends, and took over. Our heroine is a modern-day US girl -- a grouchy trailer-park teenager with pink hair -- who's been summoned to help overthrow her.

It...has its ups and downs. A female sidekick character gets killed off fairly early, in such a nasty way that I thought it had to be a fakeout, but nope. It uses the character designs from the MGM movie -- e.g. Dorothy has technicolor-red shoes (which are also evil, of course...possibly so evil that they're what caused her to go grimdark in the first place).

There was a point when I was underwhelmed, and considering dropping the book without finishing it...when suddenly Ozma shows up.

So I stuck around.

For once, a series that doesn't just take the MGM movie and make up its own backstory for everything else! The author has clearly read Baum! Ozma and Mombi both have roles in the plot., and there are cameos from later books -- the Nome King, the Shaggy Man, Polychrome. The main character has seen the movie, recognizes those characters, but is clueless about the bookverse ones, which is a shame. There's one book-backstory-related twist that she only gets in the last few pages, when I saw it coming halfway through the story.

Anyway: the whole thing builds to a confrontation which fizzles out in order to end on a sequel hook. Instead of picking up the sequels to see more beloved characters get name-dropped, I figured I'd go back to the originals.

Plus, I want to see Dorothy being awesome, not a stock Sexy Evil Overlord with Dorothy's name.

~*~*~*~

The weird thing is? In the book version of The Wizard of Oz, Dorothy does...almost nothing.

That is, she goes through a bunch of adventures, but it's all her bumbling aimlessly along whatever path someone sends her down. The party goes through challenges that (in classic fairy-tale style) are neatly solved by the Scarecrow doing smart things, the Tin Man doing loving things, and the Cowardly Lion doing brave things. Dorothy gets none of that. I kept expecting her to take initiative or make a suggestion, and nope. She's the little kid that they, parentally, protect.

Dorothy spends book 2 (The Marvelous Land of Oz) being an unseen Ozian legend, and only returns to the narrative in book 3 (Ozma of Oz) -- and, aha, here's the Dorothy I remember! It feels like a couple of years must have passed on Earth, because she's distinctly older. The story opens with her going out into a storm to rescue Uncle Henry, which is how she gets swept into adventure in the first place. She's brave and determined. She gets involved in conversations and plans with her party.

When the Wicked Witch kept her prisoner, little Dorothy obediently went along with it, doing what she was told. (In the movie, she throws water on the Witch as part of defending the Scarecrow; in the book, it's basically an accident.) When Princess Langwidere of Ev tries to order her around, older Dorothy puts her foot down, and responds to getting locked in a tower by flagging down a rescue party. Development!

Plus, there's a sequence where she's just rescued an even littler kid, and she takes on the protective caretaker role for him. Super sweet.

Book 3 is just overall such a good read. There's a complicated plot that everything ultimately fits into. The Nome King is a great villain -- I had forgotten that he isn't introduced as Obviously Unsubtly Evil. He seems jolly and affable! Dorothy's first impression is to be reminded of Santa Claus!

Then things get eerier and more ominous, one step at a time. There's a scene with Ozma in the Nome King's caverns -- it has genuine atmosphere. She has to pick the right enchanted bauble from a museum's worth of ornaments and treasures, and she only has one more guess -- so she decides to put it all in fate's hands, closes her eyes, and guesses the next thing she touches without ever seeing what it is. The writing is downright haunting.

Also, this is the book where Dorothy and Ozma meet for the first time, and instantly adore each other, and it's wonderful.

~*~*~*~

I would rec Ozma of Oz all on its own, but you gotta read books 1 and 2 first.

Even if the writing of the first book can be pretty wobbly, it's worth it just to clear all the MGM-related fanon out of your head and re-establish what's really part of bookverse continuity. For Baum's loose values of "continuity."

Book 2 puts Oz through a revolution -- literally, the palace gets taken over and everything -- which lays the groundwork for what becomes the Ozian status quo in all the books to follow.

Also: it features an early (1904!) example of literary Weird Gender Stuff, that's not treated as icky or shameful or dysfunctional in-universe. The LGBTQ appeal of Oz didn't start with Judy Garland (chill though she was). That bell had already been ringing for decades.

Book 2 is also the one that features a parody of suffragettes, and it doesn't read as terribly affectionate to modern ears. The thing to keep in mind is that Baum was an active feminist. As in "secretary of his local Women's Suffrage Club" feminist. As in "when Susan B. Anthony came to town, she crashed at his place" feminist.

So. Get your backstory down, get your worldbuilding foundations in order, then you can dive into the world of Dorothy Being Awesome and Ozma Being Elegant and general Dorothy And Ozma Being Best Girl Friends.

Profile

erinptah: (Default)
humorist + humanist

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Page generated Jul. 28th, 2025 08:35 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios

Style Credit